10 Prosecuted for murders of environmentalists

10 Prosecuted for murders of environmentalists

According to prosecutor’s hypothesis, none of the murders are linked to environmental activism against mining.

La Prensa Grafica
By Suchit Chavez
Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Translation by SHARE staff

Original Article in Spanish

On April 10th, the Court of Specialized Sentencing of San Salvador began the trial against 10 people accused of involvement in five murders, including two environmentalists that occurred in 2009 in the small community of Trinidad, in the municipality of Sensuntepeque (Department of Cabañas).

The defendants, according to prosecutors, are supposedly close to two families in the conflict.

Most of the violent deaths occurred in December 2009. Within days of each other, Ramiro Rivera, Felicita Argueta and Dora Alicia Sorto were killed in different parts of the Trinidad community. Rivera and Sorto were identified at the time as activists against active mining projects in the area. Months earlier in the same area, two relatives of a man linked to mining: Horacio Menjivar and his wife, Esperanza Velasco were also killed.

The chief prosecutor of the Organized Crime Unit (UNICCO), Rodolfo Delgado said yesterday that following his investigation, prosecutors ruled the crimes were not related to the activity of the mining company.

According to Delgado, "these families had previous quarrels with each other." Activity for and against mining exacerbated
these alleged attacks, he said.

Delgado declined to specify what the prior arguments were about, or if they had ballistic tests that connected the cases. The prosecutor stated this was due to the fact that the trial was still ongoing. He added, however, that two witnesses gave statements indicating there was allegedly a history of problems between the families.

The killing of Marcelo Rivera, another environmentalist, occurred in June 2009 in another town in Cabañas, and was disconnected by the chief prosecutor to the case currently being processed in the Court of Specialized Sentencing. In September 2010, three people were sentenced to 40 years in prison for the murder of Rivera.

Congressional Briefing: Do Trade Agreement International Investor Protections Imperil Local Communities and the Environment?

Do Trade Agreement International Investor Protections Imperil Local Communities and the Environment?

On Wednesday, March 28th Luis Gonzalez, a member of the National Roundtable against Metallic Mining in El Salvador and Unidad Ecologica de El Salvador, joined experts on investor-state disputes in Washington D.C. for a Congressional briefing organized by Public Citizen and Oxfam in coordination with Congresswoman Linda Sánchez and Congressman Raúl Grijalva.

The briefing, titled Do Trade Agreement International Investor Protections Imperil Local Communities and the Environment?, focused on how three recent investor-state cases brought by extractive industry corporations against low-income Latin American countries illustrate a stark reality: that legitimate public interest policymaking and the functions of domestic court systems are being undermined by unaccountable foreign tribunals, adversely affecting poor communities as well as national development goals.

These types of cases are especially important as the Obama administration pushes to extend investor-state provisions to many more countries through negotiations for the Trans-Pacific “free trade” agreement.

Pacific Rim Mining Corp. v. El Salvador. After failing to complete the necessary environmental protection steps to obtain a mining permit in El Salvador’s main watershed region, Canadian gold mining company Pacific Rim Mining Corp. reincorporated a Cayman island subsidiary in Nevada and then filed an investor-state suit against El Salvador under CAFTA.  The company now seeks hundreds of millions in compensation for its “lost profits” through an international tribunal, challenging the country’s mining laws. As an imminent jurisdictional ruling drags out, violence and threats against local environmentalists in the region where Pac Rim wants to run a cyanide-leach gold mine continue.

Chevron v. Ecuador. After 18 years of litigation in two countries, 30,000 indigenous peoples and farmers in Ecuador’s Amazon won a historic $18 billion ruling ordering Chevron to clean up horrific contamination of land and drinking water. But, instead of starting the long overdue clean up and provision of health care to the victims of their extreme pollution, Chevron filed an investor-state suit under the U.S-Ecuador Bilateral Investment Treaty to try to evade complying with judgments made and confirmed in U.S. and Ecuador courts. Even before it decided it had jurisdiction, a tribunal issued an order for Ecuador’s president to block enforcement of the court orders. This ruling sets a dangerous precedent, allowing deep-pocketed corporations to challenge the functions of a country’s domestic court system and the decisions of its duly-appointed judges – and would violate Ecuador’s constitutional separation of powers.

Renco v. Peru. Renco Group Inc, invested in a metal smelter in La Oroya, Peru, which has been designated as one of the top 10 most polluted sites in the world. The firm was sued in U.S. court on behalf of severely lead-poisoned children in La Oroya. Renco filed an investor-state suit under the U.S.-Peru FTA, alleging that Peru’s failure to grant it a third extension on its remediation obligations constituted a violation of the FTA investment provisions and demanding $800 million in compensation.  The mere threat of the case puts pressure on the Peruvian government to weaken its environmental and health policies, and has disrupted justice in the victims’ case in U.S. courts.

">To watch video of the briefing follow the links below. 

">Part 1, ">Part 2,

 ">Part 3,"> "> Part 4,"> Part 5,"> Part 6




El Salvador—Guns, Gold and Choice

El Salvador—Guns, Gold and Choice

In 2010 Prof. Richard Steiner, from the International Union for the Conservation of Nature and the Commission on Environmental Economic and Social Policy, visited El Salvador to investigate the actions of Canadian company Pacific Rim in the region of Cabañas.   His report El Salvador—Guns, Gold and Choice details the companies arrival in El Salvador, their law suit against the Salvadoran government for not granting them mining permits, and the response from civil society towards the mining project.  

For the full report visit here.  

Public Citizen Commerce Group Backgrounder


CAFTA Investor Rights Undermining Democracy and the Environment: Commerce Group Case

The Commerce Group Corporation, a mining firm registered and based in Wisconsin, is the second multinational company to attack El Salvador’s environmental policies under the controversial investor rights of the Central America Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA). The company’s environmental permits for its gold mining and milling operations in Northeastern El Salvador were revoked after the company failed its environmental audit; in April 2010, the Salvadoran Supreme Court ruled that the company had been accorded due process during and after the audit. 

For the full text see here…

More Articles ...

  1. Background on Mining
Design: Estudio Gráfico SV | Website by Heavy Web Design